Showing posts with label partition. Show all posts
Showing posts with label partition. Show all posts

Monday, 11 April 2022

Muslim Areas- Narrative Setting for demand for 2 partition

 Muslim Areas and the hidden  Dangerous implications 

The blog was published https://myind.net/Home/viewArticle/muslim-areas-and-the-hidden-dangerous-implications


Gargi rawat Ansari, Sreenivas Jain and many other Liberals were blaming the recent 10 April 2022 Violence and Stone pelting on peaceful happy Ramnavmi processions on Hindus taking out processions in ‘Muslim Areas’ and in front of Mosques. They were Lamenting that DJs were playing ‘Baccha baccha bolega Jai Sri Ram’ in front of Mosques. Muhammed Zubair,a  self styled fact checking Twitter handle put out a short video terming Women,Toddlers and infants dancing to Ram Bhajans as hate spreading and Provocative. The video infact showed ppl dancing in joyful abandon ,while it showed the people standing in the mosque balcony as aggressive and angry. The processions that were pelted with stones had women, children ,toddlers ,infants ,but the victims have been dehumanised to the narrative of ‘they deserved it’!

Why is the narrative of Muslim Areas so Dangerous?

Let us go back to the 14 points of Jinnah ,which were rejected by Nehru as ‘ridiculous’ and became the bedrock on which partition was demanded and Achieved .

The Fourteen Points

1)The form of the future constitution should be federal, with the residuary powers vested in the provinces.

2)All provinces must be given equal Autonomy.

3)All legislatures in the country and other elected bodies shall be constituted on the definite principle of adequate and effective representation of minorities in every province without reducing the majority in any province to a minority or even equality.

4)In the Central Legislature, Muslim representation shall not be less than one-third

5)Representation of communal groups shall continue to be by means of the separate electorate at present it shall be open to any community, at any time, to abandon its separate electorate in favor of joint electorate.

6)Any territorial distribution that might at any time be necessary shall not in any way affect the Muslim majority in Punjab, Bengal and NWFP provinces.

7)Full religious liberty shall be guaranteed to all communities.

8)No bill or resolution shall be passed in any legislature if three-fourths of the members of any community in that body oppose the bill.

9)Sindh should be separated from the Bombay To a province.

10)Reforms should be introduced in the NWFP and Balochistan on the same footings as in the other provinces.

11)Muslims should be given an adequate share in all services, having due regard to the requirement of efficiency.

12)The Constitution should embody adequate safeguards for the protection of Muslim culture, education, language, religion and personal laws, as well as for Muslim charitable institutions.

13)One-third representation shall be given to Muslims in both central and provincial cabinets.

14)No change will be made in the constitution without the consent of the provinces.

A part of the 14 points reads like the Constitution of the Islamic republic of Pakistan.

If we analyse the first 2 demands, the Dangerous nature of Rahul Gandhi speech in parliament questioning the unitary  structure of India becomes Apparent . BR Ambedkar ,very wisely, turned India into a union of states ,not a federation ,with centre being the power that held the unitary structure together. 

The demand for separate electorate for muslims, their representation in central government, not tinkering with territories to change Muslim demographics etc are just what ‘Muslim Areas’ represent . The presumption seems that the writ of constitution does not run in areas which are adjoining mosques or have Muslim majority. The areas are ‘No go Areas’ for non Muslims. It also implies that if any religious activity that runs counter to Islam is Carried out,It is but fair to get retribution.

This Narrative is very dangerous to the very unity and social structure of Bharat. In majority of areas, processions and Ram Navmi celebrations went on peacefully, but in certain areas, designated by Left Liberals as ‘Muslim Areas’ , there was stone pelting and violence .

Horrors of partition that Hindus faced were again blamed on Hindus . Reactions to Muslims during wide spread riots was blamed on violence on fleeing Hindus in east and west Pakistan . The same narrative was used to justify invasion of Jammu and Kashmir by Pakistani army and Tribals. The invasion resulted in wide spread murders,rapes and conversions of Hindus and Sikhs in Mirpur ,Muzzafarabad ,Gilgit,Skardu and Kashmir valley. Again this was blamed on Hindus killing Muslims and again the victims were dehumanised.

The Genocide of Kashmiri Hindus was rationalised as an uprising of suppressed Muslims (95% population) against Kashmiri Hindu (5%) because they were cornering all benefits. This was a lie as in post 1947 Jammu Kashmir, state employment was not given to Kashmiri Hindus as a policy of sheikh Abdullah. Hindus were not given admission in Srinagar colleges. The nominations of Hindu candidates of praja parishad were cancelled . The one lone Seat of Habbakadal, won by a Kashmiri Hindu ,was delimited to prevent a recurrence of the same, yet the 1989-1990 Genocide was normalised . Kashmir Valley was a ‘Muslim area’ where the rule was to leave ,convert or Die / Hindu women to be given to Muslims.

Every year, on Ashura, Muharram processions pass peacefully through ‘Hindu Areas’ . It is when they enter ‘Muslim Areas’ that they are Attacked. So who is   ‘Zaleel’ here ? Rana Ayyub termed Hindus dancing in Gay Abandon to Sri Ram Bhajans as Zaleel , as they were in front of a Mosque! 

The Fact that Muslim Area became an instant trend on Twitter is testimony to the fact that Indian citizens will not take attempts to divide India into communal Zones laying down.

This Narrative is very dangerous and needs to be countered .



Wednesday, 11 December 2019

Mishtar Jinnah says Hindus will be safe in Pakistan..Untold story of broken faith

She wore only black and never tied her hair till her death..after being forced to abandon her home in Sialkot and migrate to India post partition...
The wounds of Partition are generational. The pain of the unhealed wounds is so deep that partition and pre partition life was never discussed in my family while I was growing up in Meerut ,which was my Grandmother’s ( Dadi) hometown . Any questions about my Father’s paternal family would be answered with a bland “ they belonged to Sialkot and came to Meerut/ Delhi post partition” . My grandmother’s eyes would moisten . She would sometimes speak of my grandfather ,who was subedar major in British Army, being posted to Chaman and they wanting to settle there ...but then partition happened!
We grew up with knowing a lot about Meerut and my Dadi’s family roots in Meerut, but strangely nothing about my Father’s ‘Sialkot’ Dada-Dadi. We grew up with a nostalgia about Chaman where my grandmother was Happy and dreamt of settling till partition happened.
Recently Kartarpur corridor was opened and  my Aunts( my late father’s sisters), in their late seventies and eighties suddenly opened up about the Sialkot past. This blog is a very very belated attempt to bring out my great grandmother’s  voice through silence of Generations and bring forth the great human tragedy of partition..a tragedy which has been normalised and foot noted for my generation and coming ones .
My Father’s Grandfather was Sri Govind Ram Sharma,an army contractor with the British settled in Sialkot . He was an Arya Samaji. My aunt claims a Gate of Aryasamaj in Sialkot had his name inscribed . My Grandfather’s name was Munshi Lal Sharma and my Great Grandmother’s name was Shiv Devi.
By all accounts ,my Great Grandmother Shiv Devi was a very strong woman and committed aryasamaji. She built a large home in Sialkot and several other commercial properties. A property under the name of her Son ,munshi Lal Sharma ,housed a post office. She donated to an aryasamaj school which had my grandfather’s name ,Munshi Lal inscribed in The wall . My aunt recalls seeing the gate and the post office as a child during visits to Sialkot. 
Shiv Devi Ji was a beautiful woman, and was widowed early. However she managed her properties etc and was deeply respected in her neighbourhood. There was one room with a kaccha floor where the family gold was buried and boxes full of clothes were placed in the room. Once a year ,Shiv Devi, along with a group of women ,would go to Kashmir and bring back an year’s supply of dry fruits and warm clothes. It seems that it was a common practise in areas of Punjab to go to Kashmir and bring dry fruits and warm clothes.
Shiv Devi helped her neighbours and was deeply respected as she was always there for them . She also had a fiery temper which was often unleashed on unsuspecting strangers. One anecdote my aunt narrates is of her asking a Baraat to take another route as there was another baraat awaited in her neighbourhood, and the baraat complying with her ..and changing the route!
Partition was imminent and my grandfather, who had left the British army and shifted to meerut in a rented house , advised her to sell her house and come to Meerut too. But Shiv Devi had just repaired her home and was well established. She told everyone..Mishtar Jinnah has promised Hindus will be safe in Pakistan ..why should I leave my home and life I know.
Partition happened and bloodshed followed. There was no population migration planned but Hindus were under attack. My Great grandmom would still claim..Mishtar Jinnah has assured..but she sent her unmarried daughter, who was a beauty to Her Relatives in Dehradun. Then her Muslim neighbours would advise her to cross the border and go to safety, but she resisted , staying all alone in her house,guarding her family gold buried under the mud floor.
One night, mobs went on a rampage in her neighbourhood , killing, raping and looting Hindus. Her Muslim neighbours came into her home via a ladder and told her to come with them . They told her they could not bear to see her being dishonoured and they would take her across the border. My grandmother had no time to take out her buried gold, except one gold bangle, weighing 8 tolas, before she was hustled across the ladder into her Muslim neighbour home and escorted to the border where she crossed over and reached Delhi.
My aunt recollects that Shiv Devi started wearing black to convey her protest and stopped tying her hair. She vowed that she would tie up her hair only after returning to her home. But that was never to be!
One day, when she was living with her daughter in Delhi, she met a neighbour from Sialkot . He was a Muslim and was visiting his relatives. She saw him and bought him home. She wanted to know about her home and properties. The man told her her house had been occupied by several Muslim families and her mud floor had been dug up and her gold looted. The post office was still functioning in in the Property named after Munshi Lal Sharma, her beloved son. After this meeting my Great Grandmother had changed a lot, and stopped discussing Sialkot. Our family had left everything behind in Sialkot , all family savings, land, buildings to start life afresh in a rented house. We had very financially weak childhoods..my grandmother through her tireless housekeeping fed us,clothed us and sent us to the best schools. Yet, the image management of Nehru was so great that my grandmother remained a committed congressi till her last breath We too, though partition was an inevitable price to pay for freedom from British! But now I think, had partition not happened, the family wealth would have been built upon,the family home built with love,tears and sweat would have been there,we may have been born in the family home of Sialkot,and my grandmother would have lived comfortably instead of struggling in near poverty to bring up her children and grandchildren! It is us second generation that is now comfortably settled,but two generations before us suffered and struggled! Time we discuss the horrors of partition and stop normalising it and letting it become a footnote in history!